DHOUSE PATTANA PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: DHOUSE🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

Internal Control Summary:

1. The organization demonstrates a commitment to the values of integrity and ethics. The Company has established charters for various Board Committees, a Good Corporate Governance Policy, a Code of Conduct, policies and procedures regarding related party transactions, and operational and transactional authorization limits. The Board of Directors is required to perform its duties in accordance with the law, objectives, and regulations of the Company, in line with the principles of good corporate governance as guided by the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission, under ethical, honest, transparent, and prudent operations to protect the interests of the Company, without causing conflicts of interest between stakeholders and the Company, as specified in the Good Corporate Governance Policy.

2. The Board of Directors is independent from the management and performs oversight and development of internal control operations. The Company has defined the scope, authority, and responsibilities of the Board of Directors and sub-committees, consisting of (1) the Board of Directors Charter, (2) the Audit Committee Charter, (3) the Management Committee Charter, (4) the Nomination and Remuneration Committee Charter, (5) the Risk Management Committee Charter, (6) the Chief Executive Officer Charter, and (7) the Company Secretary Charter. The specific authority of each committee is defined in writing, separating their roles and responsibilities from the management, and the authorization limits are clearly defined and reviewed in the "Authorization Manual."

3. The management has established a reporting line structure, defined authority in command and appropriate responsibilities to enable the organization to achieve its objectives, under the oversight of the Board of Directors. The Board of Directors has approved the organizational structure defined by the management and clearly approved by the Board of Directors' meeting, which supports the achievement of the Company's objectives. The organizational structure is divided into departments according to the nature of the business and the law, including appropriate internal controls, such as segregation of duties in key functions of the accounting and finance departments to separate the duties of auditors and bookkeepers, defining the scope of authority for operations and authorization limits, and hiring internal auditors from external firms to conduct quarterly audits and assess the effectiveness of the Company's internal control and report directly to the Audit Committee on an ongoing basis.

4. The organization demonstrates a commitment to motivating, developing, and retaining competent personnel. The Company has established a Human Resources Management Policy and operational procedures for "Recruitment, Selection, and Employment" to guide the recruitment and selection of employees based on the job specifications defined in the job descriptions.

In terms of personnel development, the Company has established work procedures for "Individual Development Plan for Succession Planning" and "Training and Development," which clearly define the guidelines for employee development.

5. The organization assigns personnel with duties and responsibilities for internal control to achieve the organization's objectives. The Board of Directors and management have established policies to control the overall operations of the organization, such as the Good Corporate Governance Policy and the Code of Ethics and Conduct Policy. There are communication processes through orientation for new employees and on-the-job training by supervisors. An external internal audit firm is hired to review the appropriateness of the operating procedures and report the audit results to the Audit Committee.


Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)231815

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
Within (month/year)2022-032022-03
The land development plan does not cover the entire area owned by the company.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company has a land development plan, which includes estimated construction and sales timelines for the project. However, it does not encompass all land holdings owned by the company. The Director of Business Development, Marketing, and Sales stated that the company will be reviewing a new comprehensive land development plan.

Within (month/year)2022-032022-03
The organizational structure of the project construction department has a position structure that is inconsistent with the defined main structure and has inappropriate segregation of duties according to the chain of command.
Incident no longer subject to action

according to the structure approved on January 14, 2022.

• The main organizational structure chart and the sub-organizational structure chart are clearly consistent and aligned with current operations.

• Human Resources and General Administration officers still maintain the practice of substituting for each other to prevent loss, which is not appropriate due to being in different chains of command. The executives are in the process of reviewing the chains of command in the new organizational structure to be suitable for the current personnel and situation, and will consider separating the chains of command again if there is a tendency for projects to increase.

Within (month/year)2022-062022-06
The 2022 business plan indicates an excessively high investment amount allocated to PTT Station projects under Dhouse. This discrepancy arises from the direct investment made by D-Energy & Retail Company Limited, which is incorrectly included in the total investment figure.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company is in the process of reviewing the investment budget plan for the service station projects of both DHouse Pattana Public Company Limited and D Energy & Retail Company Limited, including the budget for the construction costs of other projects, and will propose it to the Board of Directors for approval on August 15, 2022.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The "Policy and Procedures for Related Party Transactions" and "Policy for Review of Relationships with Sellers" specify the procedures to be followed once a related party transaction is identified. However, they do not explicitly state when to check for such transactions.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should consider clear guidelines for reviewing intercompany transactions, such as

- Review before the first transaction with that counterparty.

- Review whether the counterparties are related persons or entities every 3 months or 6 months, etc.

then revise the policies and procedures for intercompany transactions to be clear and communicate them to relevant parties for proper implementation.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The procurement department does not have a Vendor Application Form to assess suitability and grant approval before registering vendors in the system according to the regulations.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should emphasize that the person responsible for preparing the Vendor Application Form must include important details such as name, address, telephone number, and selection date. It is also recommended to present the list of selected vendors to authorized personnel for approval before registering them in the system. This serves as evidence to consider the suitability and existence of vendors before recording their information in the company's system.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The company does not verify the connections of customers and does not clearly establish documentation for verifying the connections of employees and directors with each contractor/service provider.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should establish and enforce the verification of related parties by referring to the "Policy and Procedure on Related Party Transactions" and the "Vendor Relationship Review Policy".

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The company possesses capital assets not listed in the approved BOQ, and these assets were acquired without explicit approval through a documented off-budget request process.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should urge relevant personnel, including procurement staff and those responsible for budget estimation and cost control, to verify that purchase orders for goods or materials align with the BOQ or established budget. In cases of purchases exceeding the BOQ or budget, approval documents should be prepared, including a BOQ deviation request and authorization from authorized personnel. This approval process for BOQ deviations should be followed in all instances to ensure adherence to established procedures and controls.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
Policies and Announcements Regarding Personal Data Protection Act Compliance: - Incomplete information regarding the appointment of a Personal Data Protection Officer working group. - Communication to sellers/service providers has not yet been conducted. - A draft "Record of Processing Activities" has been prepared, but activities related to data in the procurement system have not yet been specified.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should review the draft Privacy Notice to ensure completeness in important matters and present it to authorized personnel for approval and issuance along with the Privacy Policy. The company should also communicate the Privacy Notice to relevant external parties and prepare consent forms or Personal Information Request Forms.

• In cases of contracts or transactions with partners or using services from service providers, the purposes and practices of personal data processing under the basis of data processing must be disclosed and consent must be obtained. This can be done by notifying the request to use or collect information through procurement documents, vendor/partner registration documents, or through a Privacy Notice in the selection system, etc.

• A survey of existing personal data should be conducted and a "Record of Processing Activities" should be created to clearly specify the activities for data related to the procurement system.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The company has inadequate authorization controls related to the information technology systems in place for critical matters, such as reviewing logs for various events and testing data recovery.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should define the scope of authority related to information technology systems to cover the review of logs in various cases and data recovery testing. It should also be presented to authorized persons for approval and enforcement to ensure that employees can properly request permission to carry out various activities.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The company has established a clear personal data protection policy and the purpose of collecting each type of personal data. However, there is no signed approval for its announcement and enforcement.
Incident no longer subject to action

The established policies and measures regarding the control, supervision, and protection of personal data should be presented to authorized persons for approval and communicated to all employees.

Within (month/year)2022-092022-09
The company does not have measures in place to control personal data stored in Information Technology (IT) systems. There is no inventory of personal data that needs to be stored in the company's database. Additionally, there is no clear record of processing activities related to personal data (ROPA).
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should establish measures to control personal data stored in information technology (IT) systems, and submit them for approval and announcement by authorized persons. These measures should comprehensively address crucial aspects such as preventing unauthorized access to electronic systems, controlling data loss or damage, data correction, personal data transmission, electronic device control, and personal data protection testing.

• The company should survey personal data required to be stored in its database system and create a table recording processing activities related to personal data, known as the Record of Processing Activities (ROPA). This enables the data controller to control and prevent data processors from using or disclosing personal data inappropriately or in violation of applicable laws.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
There is no actual performance tracking information compared to the approved short-term plan.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should compile comparative data on actual operations against the established plan and report it to the management regularly.

• The company should urge the operators to collect operational data in real-time and identify the causes of any deviations from the plan, including specifying clear solutions or courses of action.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
The company has appointed an acting officer in a higher position (the Head of Financial Planning, where the acting officer is a Finance Officer). Additionally, there are positions where individuals have been acting for over a year, specifically the Head of Human Resources and General Administration and the Loss Prevention Officer.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should consider assigning acting roles only at equivalent or lower job levels.

• For positions with acting roles for an extended period, the company should consider whether the scope of the acting assignment is appropriate and whether the uncovered work is necessary, in order to consider restructuring or expedite the recruitment process.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
The company did not review the long-term manpower plan of the Human Resources and General Administration departments (due to changes in the number of projects) and did not specify the reasons for not recruiting personnel according to the plan (found in 3 out of 24 cases).
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should review the long-term manpower plan to align with the business plan and organizational structure. It should survey the manpower requirements of each department and specify the number of personnel required to perform all tasks in all functions of every department at each period. The plan should be presented to authorized persons for approval.

• In case the recruitment does not go according to plan, the cause should be clearly stated and reported to relevant persons regularly. In the event that recruitment does not proceed as planned

The date specified in the "Manpower Requisition Form" should clearly state the reason. This serves as evidence for communication, enabling the requesting department to effectively manage and operate while waiting for recruitment.

Within (month/year)2022-122022-12
There is no onboarding documentation for new employees as specified in the work procedures, and recruitment documents are incomplete, such as bank account copies, medical certificates, and military conscription certificates.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should urge staff to prepare documents related to employee recruitment and specify complete important details. In addition, staff should be urged to check the accuracy of all information or documents and collect application documents and other supporting documents. Store them in the employee's history file for timely retrospective verification.

Within (month/year)2023-032023-03
The manual lacks comprehensive operational procedures, particularly in areas like: (1) Scrutinizing transactions or related dealings between employees, management, and clients. (2) Aligning with current operational practices, such as handling customer refunds and transfers, developing marketing plans, and evaluating and selecting advertising channels.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should review the manual to cover all important operating procedures. It should also be aligned with current operations and submitted to authorized personnel for approval and promulgation.

• The revised operational manual should be communicated to employees immediately to ensure that operations are carried out in accordance with the established procedures. Employees should also be required to report on the internal control plan and regulations when operating procedures change so that the operational manual is updated accordingly.

Within (month/year)2023-032023-03
The Grand Beach project was granted a discount/reduction for a customer seminar in March, resulting in a lower gross profit margin than approved by the Board of Directors in the 2023 short-term plan by 7.15%. The approver of this transaction did not follow the established authorization manual. The designated authority to approve "pricing structure and gross profit margin" is the Managing Director. However, in practice, the Board of Directors approves the gross profit margin for each project in the business plan.
Incident no longer subject to action

• In consideration of approving promotional discounts, the company should estimate the gross profit using data on selling price, promotional discounts for each month, and compare it with the rate approved by the Board of Directors. The company should clearly present the difference in gross profit and submit it to the authorized person according to the authorization.

• The company should review the authorization of "Pricing Structure, Gross Profit Margin" for the project. The authorized person should be designated as the Board of Directors.

Within (month/year)2023-062023-06
The U-Park Market project lacks a product layout plan and has disorganized product placement as follows: - Construction materials and products are not categorized or separated by type, such as PVC pipes, cement, and paint. - Torn bags of cement are found without proper storage or utilization.
Incident no longer subject to action

• A product layout plan should be created, clearly dividing areas or zones for storing usable and expired or long-stocked items. This plan should be presented to authorized personnel for approval and implementation. It is also essential to communicate to stock handlers the need to store goods and construction materials according to the designated layout plan.

• When damage to product/material/equipment packaging is detected, the relevant departments should be notified immediately to determine the cause and appropriate handling or storage methods. A summary of problems arising from warehouse management should be compiled to be used as a control activity to assess risks and monitor outcomes, preventing the recurrence of errors.

Within (month/year)2023-092023-09
The following observations were made regarding the authorization of procurement, hiring, and payment: - Inconsistent with current operations: The person who has the authority to approve the cancellation of purchase orders (P/O). - Inappropriate: The person who has the authority to approve payments via Internet Banking. Currently, only one person has this authorization. - Does not cover important matters: - Authority to approve the cancellation of employment contracts. - Authority to sign tax deduction at source certificates.
Incident no longer subject to action

The power of attorney manual should be reviewed. The scope of authorization should cover all types of procurement systems and disbursements, and

The level of approval authority should be appropriate and consistent with the current management structure. The following significant activities should be proposed to the Executive Committee for approval:

- Authorization to cancel purchase requisitions (EM103_2)

- Authority to sign withholding tax certificates

- Authorization to cancel purchase orders (P/O)

- Authorization for Internet Banking transactions.

Within (month/year)2023-092023-09
The cancellation of Purchase Orders (POs) lacks proper authorization from authorized personnel as stipulated in the partner's procedures. In practice, the Purchasing Officer (the highest-ranking position in the Procurement Department, equivalent to a Head) only affixes a "Cancelled" stamp and indicates the reason for cancellation. The PO is not forwarded to authorized personnel for approval. Additionally, the Purchasing Officer has been granted system cancellation rights, which deviates from established protocols.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should emphasize the approval process for signing or countersigning the cancellation of purchase orders (POs) with a clear indication of evidence. The approver should be in accordance with the guidelines stipulated in the operational manual and authorization handbook. This serves as evidence that the cancellation of the purchase order (PO) has been reviewed and approved by the authorized personnel.

Within (month/year)2023-092023-09
The legal advisory agreements lack crucial details (Office of the Judiciary), such as the contract duration (start and end dates), confidentiality clauses, and terms for contract termination/breach. Additionally, there are no formal contracts in place for engaging law firms on a case-by-case basis (Jaran Lawyers Office).
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should consider preparing a clear service agreement or external consultant agreement every time it hires and consult with the legal department to ensure that the following important matters are fully stated, such as

- Scope of work

- Employment period (Start - End)

- Compensation

- Confidentiality

- Termination, Breach of contract

- Having both authorized parties sign the contract before commencing work to ensure that the terms and conditions constitute a clear agreement between the two parties to prevent any disputes that may arise later.

Within (month/year)2023-092023-09
There are instances of goods receipts being signed off by warehouse staff or drivers, which contradicts the authorized personnel matrix (stipulating a value not exceeding 100,000 baht to be signed by Department Managers/Heads of Department). Additionally, there are incomplete signatures on goods receipts.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should urge relevant personnel to verify the completeness and accuracy of signatures on documents to ensure proper consideration and review.

Goods, with authorization by authorized personnel in accordance with the authorization manual.

• In cases where the procedures stipulated in the authorization manual are not practically feasible, a review and revision should be considered to align with current operational practices. However, this must be conducted within the framework of a sound internal control system and submitted for approval by authorized personnel before official implementation.

Within (month/year)2023-092023-09
The authorization process for Internet Banking transactions is inappropriate for the following reasons: - Currently, the company primarily uses Internet Banking for payments and transfers. The authorization for these transactions is solely assigned to the "Chief Executive Officer." While the "Director of Accounting and Finance" has been provided with user access and OTP to perform payments on certain occasions. - The use of Token has been discontinued. Currently, an OTP is sent to the "Chief Executive Officer" mobile phone. However, there has been no review or update of the Finance Department's policies to reflect this change.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should review the authorization settings for Internet Banking transactions across all banks to require approval from at least two authorized individuals. This ensures an appropriate system of checks and balances for authorization.

• Payments via Internet Banking should be conducted in accordance with the authority defined and enforced by the company. Payment authorization must be made by authorized company personnel whose names are registered with the bank. This measure serves as a check and balance to prevent errors or payments that deviate from company regulations.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
There are no policies and work manuals covering certain important matters, such as policies and manuals on salary structure determination and procedures for education/employment history verification. These are currently under review to ensure they are appropriate and aligned with current operations, such as the Human Resources Management Work Manual (DHP-WM-03).
Incident no longer subject to action

There should be a review of policies, manuals, and operating procedures related to human resource management systems, salary, and wage payments to cover all

Important and appropriate activities are aligned with current operations, and clearly proposed to authorized personnel for approval. This serves as a guideline for work and reduces the risk of misunderstandings in the work process.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
The delegation of authority for the human resource management system, monthly payroll, and wages does not cover some important matters such as approval of probationary performance evaluations, both in cases of pass/fail and leave (annual vacation leave), etc. Moreover, some authorizations are not appropriately defined, such as approval of personnel budgets, approval of overtime work, and performance evaluations, etc.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should review the authorization manual by specifying the approval authority related to the human resource management system, salary, and wage payments.

It covers all important matters appropriate to the level of approval and is consistent with the current management structure and job positions. It also proposes

The Board of Directors considers and approves before enforcement.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
Important documents are not stored properly. The document storage room lacks doors or locks (e.g., monthly payroll and personal information, including Social Security files, PND.1 files, KPI files, and Provident Fund files). Additionally, document storage is incomplete (copies of director's meeting attendance fees).
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should improve the storage area for information and documents, perhaps by storing them in cabinets with closing doors/drawers and locking them when not in use or unattended. Access to the keys should be limited to designated personnel, specifically the human resources and general affairs planner. The company should also consider measures to enhance the security and strictness of entry and exit to the room by unauthorized individuals. Additionally, the company should emphasize to the staff the importance of making complete copies of documents related to director's meeting attendance fees and filing them in the directors' records every time such fees are paid.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
Employee onboarding documents are incomplete, with inconsistent details and missing information in employee files. Issues include: 1) Lack of manpower requisition forms. 2) Missing employee handbook summaries in personnel files. 3) Interview evaluation forms lacking scores for all criteria. 4) Incomplete signatures on employment contracts, including missing signatures from the "employer," "witnesses," and "HR personnel."
Incident no longer subject to action

• It should be emphasized that documentation throughout the recruitment and onboarding process is prepared and stored comprehensively, adhering to established operational procedures. This serves as evidence of fair and transparent operations, enabling immediate and retrospective audits.

• Employees should be urged to thoroughly review documents related to employee onboarding, ensuring all essential details are included before submitting them for approval by authorized personnel. This prevents the presentation of incomplete or insufficient information for their consideration.

• It should be emphasized that those involved in signing the employment contract must do so completely and accurately to ensure that all operations are carried out by authorized personnel as determined by the company.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
Sales department employees are compensated with benefits as stipulated in the benefits policy. However, the payment amounts vary depending on the travel location, and this information is not explicitly stated in the employment contract or any attached documents.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should establish clear guidelines for fuel and travel allowance benefits for reference and appropriate payment approval in accordance with

each off-site operation.

• Or, in the case of determining a fixed rate for each individual as agreed upon, the conditions of the "fuel and travel allowance" benefits for salespeople should be clearly specified in the employment agreement. In the case of providing benefits to employees afterward, a memorandum should be prepared at the end of the employment agreement, stating the employee's name, job position, benefits received, and effective date, along with submitting it to the authorized person for approval, clearly attached to the employment agreement.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
The training plan for 2023 was deemed inappropriate as it was based on the 2022 plan without referencing the training needs assessment for 2023. The training plan for 2024 is currently being developed and is expected to be finalized by December. Additionally, there have been discrepancies found between recorded training outcomes and actual results, and there is a lack of follow-up on training conducted as per the plan.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should establish an annual training plan by referencing data from the annual needs survey, including consideration of courses required by law or courses that the management deems important and necessary for employees to attend.

• Human Resources and General Administration should regularly monitor the training according to the established plan and should communicate to employees who have attended the training to submit supporting training documents immediately upon returning to the company.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
The annual salary adjustment was not made within the specified timeframe (salary adjustment evaluation period is in November, which the CEO announced that employee salaries had been reviewed and adjusted on December 26, 2023, but IA has not yet received the information). Moreover, the salary adjustment used employee KPI assessment data from 2022, which may be inappropriate.
Incident no longer subject to action

• The company should have a process for considering and adjusting salaries in accordance with the stipulated cycle and the resolution approving the annual salary adjustment budget for permanent employees, which is always presented to the Remuneration and Nomination Committee and the Board of Directors.

• The company should consider reviewing the cycle of employee performance evaluation data used in salary adjustments to ensure it is appropriately aligned with the current salary adjustment period.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
The following documents used in the resignation process do not comply with the manual: 1) Employee Resignation Form 2) Resignation Application Form 3) Termination of Employment Notification 4) Pre-Resignation Checklist Form
Incident no longer subject to action

Complete resignation documentation should be prepared in accordance with the Human Resources Management Manual (0552-63F-65). The accuracy and completeness of the information, including the signatures of those involved in the resignation process, should be verified before the employee's last day of employment. This ensures traceability and prevents errors or disputes that may arise later.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
The Username and Password termination documents were incompletely processed, and approval was granted by the manager after the employee's departure. (Employee termination date: September 24, 2023, and termination approval date: September 29, 2023)
Incident no longer subject to action

Information Technology personnel should prepare a form for requesting the cancellation of Username and Password and proceed to request permission to revoke access rights or terminate access to all work systems, including E-mail, as soon as they are aware that the employee has terminated their employment.

Within (month/year)2023-122023-12
There is no provident fund refund report, and the provident fund refund is overdue. (The law requires a refund within 7 days from the date of termination by the employer, the date of resignation by the employee, or the date of insurance contract expiry) and as specified in the manual (the manual specifies a refund within 30 days after the one-month period following the effective resignation date). The one-month period has expired.
Incident no longer subject to action

• A comprehensive report on employee deposit refunds should be prepared.

• Consideration should be given to proceeding at least within the timeframe specified in the Human Resources Management Manual (DHP-WM-03), and there should be clear communication or agreement with employees. This is to prevent disputes in case of lawsuits from resigned employees who have not received their job security deposits within the specified period.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
The company's procedures related to project construction control and management do not cover current practices. The following issues were observed: - Regulation DHP-ICL-27 (Construction, Modification, or Demolition Permit Application Procedure) does not specify the responsible personnel or the process for monitoring the status of construction permits. - The Construction Supervision Department's Work Manual (DHP-WP-W)4-09) does not define the steps for inspecting houses before delivery to the sales department and lacks a procedure for preparing the EM106 form for contractor performance inspections.
Implemented

The company should review the manual/working procedures. It should be stipulated to cover all important activities and be consistent with current operations, along with clearly proposing authorized persons for approval.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
The construction planning process lacks adherence to the established manual, relying instead on the 2567 construction plan and budget alongside Progress files to monitor and ensure alignment with the stipulated percentage of completion. Currently, the company is reevaluating the formats and methodologies employed in construction planning across all projects to enhance clarity. Furthermore, there are ongoing efforts to revise the operational manual to better reflect actual practices.
Implemented

• Construction plans should be prepared for all projects, and in cases where the construction plan is clear, a disbursement plan should be prepared in accordance with the established construction plan.

• Construction work should be monitored according to the established plan, and in the event that the construction work does not go according to plan, an impact analysis should be conducted and a report should be clearly submitted to management for acknowledgement.

• In cases where the clarity of the operational plan format has been considered, the manual and operating procedures should be reviewed for consistency with actual operations that have changed and submitted to the authorized signatory for approval and announcement.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
The preparation of contractor access plan documents is done in the form of a "Contractor Access Plan" document specifically for the Pruksa Pirom project. This is because it is necessary to control the access of a large number of contractors. In other projects, there is no clear documentation for controlling contractor work. Currently, the preparation of such documents and the details of the process are not clearly defined in the operational manual for use in controlling work in the same direction for all projects.
Incident no longer subject to action

• Consideration should be given to requiring the preparation of contractor call-in work plans for all projects in order to control daily construction operations and supervise construction contractors more effectively.

• The Construction Management Manual (DAP-WA6-09) should be reviewed by specifying the operational procedures for controlling daily construction operations and supervising construction contractors, including how they should be carried out, what documents to use, and the timeframe for document preparation. The manual should also clearly indicate who has the authority to approve the plan.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Compliance with regulations for electricians working inside buildings. Currently employed electricians do not possess the qualifications stipulated by the Enhancement and Development of Workforce Skills Act B.E. 2557 (2014), which designates in-building electricians as a profession potentially hazardous to the public, requiring them to pass a test for a "Certificate of Competency." Additionally, their Job Descriptions lack specific qualification requirements.
Implemented

• Electricians of the company should be required to take the test in order to obtain a "Certificate of Competency" as required by law (except for electrical engineers who have a license to practice electrical engineering).

• Once completed, the HR department should keep the certificate in the employee's personnel file to reference the electrician's qualifications as required by law and specify the qualifications in the electrician's JD.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Inspection - The Grand Canal (UR) and Prukbhirom (PS) projects have incomplete preparation/storage of construction standard documents in the work categories that have already been carried out according to the actual % Progress data, such as plastering, tiling, etc. - Construction standard documents, specifically for the Prukbhirom (PS) project, have incomplete "Acknowledged and Complied with" (contractor) signatures for some items (house plots TWP-62, TWP-63, TWP-64, work code PS150, exterior ceiling work - upper round).
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should communicate and emphasize that both ongoing and new projects must prepare and maintain complete construction standard documents for all work codes, covering the work of both employees and contractors.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
There is no clear record of defect statistics found during the final inspection before delivery to sales or customers. In practice, defects are inspected before handover to sales or customers using a document called "Official Notice for Defect Collection and Pre-Transfer Photography." This document lists rectification works, which can be used to collect statistical data for improving the construction process.
Implemented

The company should collect statistical data on the list and causes of defects that occur before delivering houses to the sales department or customers. This data should include an analysis of the causes, severity levels, potential impacts, and whether they fall within acceptable business norms. This information can then be used to support the development and improvement of construction processes and standards, or to enhance the efficiency of contractors in future project operations.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
The inspection of machinery used in construction and the verification of operator qualifications for the Upark Home project revealed that external contractors were hired for foundation and pile driving work. These contractors utilized their own machinery, including cranes, for the tasks. While the physical condition and operational readiness of the machinery were inspected, no formal documentation of these inspections was maintained. Additionally, there was no verification of the machine operator licenses prior to the commencement of work.
Implemented

The procedures for inspecting construction machinery and verifying operator qualifications should be clearly defined in regulations or operational manuals. Additionally, inspection forms for machinery and operator readiness should be established, specifying the necessary inspection points comprehensively.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Safety management control in construction projects does not comply with the "Emergency Decree on the Appointment of Occupational Safety Officers, Personnel, Agencies, or Groups of Persons to Carry Out Safety in Establishments B.E. 2565 (2022)" resulting in the following not being implemented: - Preparation of a manual on safety, occupational health, and working environment. - Communicating safety regulations to all employees for their access and self-study. - Training for employees before they start working at the construction site. - Preparing monthly safety reports to be submitted to government agencies. Observations from the safety control monitoring in the projects are as follows: - The Grand Canal Project (UR): No fire extinguishers are installed within the site office. - Prukkarom Project (PS): No fire extinguishers are installed within the site office, and there is no dedicated occupational safety officer as required due to the estimated number of employees at the site exceeding 20 people (currently supervised by an engineer).
Implemented

The company should appoint a safety officer as required by law, and once the safety officer has been appointed, the following should be implemented:

- Develop a manual on safety, occupational health, and working environment.

- Communicate safety regulations to all employees for their access and self-study.

- Train employees before they start working at every construction site.

- Prepare safety reports to be submitted to government agencies every month.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Preparation of Construction Budget Monitoring and Control Data The company's preparation of construction budget monitoring and control data for January and February 2024 is delayed. The details are as follows: - Reports comparing % variance (Budget / BOO) and cost reports, including comparisons by cost percentage. - Progress on EM105 (Engineer's Estimate) and Cost Sheets for each project. This delay is due to incorrect recording of construction material usage data, which is currently under review for correction. As a result, the company is unable to prepare construction budget monitoring and control data for reporting to management within the specified timeframe.
Incident no longer subject to action

Construction budget tracking and control information should be prepared, and progress reports should be submitted to management within the specified timeframe. This allows for timely review and adjustment of project costs (BOQ) in critical work categories, in accordance with company guidelines.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Defining budget access rights in the @Con system: The company's defined access and usage rights for project budgets and individual house budgets within the @Con system are inappropriate, as follows: - All departments can access and utilize the BOQ budget system, including recording, editing, unlocking in case of exceeding the budget. Additionally, the project planning and cost estimation department can access and use other systems such as accounts payable, accounts receivable, sales, accounting, and inventory systems. - Access rights for both operational staff and department head levels are identical, including adding, editing, deleting, and canceling transactions, without appropriate access limitations based on job positions.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should review user access and usage rights for the @Con system to ensure they are appropriate. Access should be granted based on job levels and responsibilities as defined in the job description documents. Unauthorized individuals should not be granted access to perform any actions within the system.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Preparation of Receiving and Issuing Documents: The internal auditor did not receive the receiving and issuing documents as per the Warehouse Management Manual (DHP-WM-10). Due to the resignation of the warehouse officer and the lack of handover, the documents could not be located for audit. The details of the unaudited documents are as follows: - Purchase Order P/O 03 and Goods Receipt Note from PO 03 (PO05) in written form, totaling 10 items. - Goods Receipt Note P/O 05 2, totaling 8 items. - Goods Issue Note D-Store from the central warehouse, totaling 11 items.
Incident no longer subject to action

If there is a change of personnel, it should be emphasized that the handover of work must be completed thoroughly. It should also be emphasized that documents must be filed systematically, separated by document list, arranged by date, and filed in folders for each month. This includes cases where documents are filed as a set; a register of document sets should be created and attached to the front of the file for immediate traceability. This ensures that errors reported by relevant agencies can be promptly investigated.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Recording of Goods Issue From a random inspection of the requisition forms, it was found that there were delays in recording goods issues in the @Con system (13 items from AP warehouse and 12 items from UR warehouse). The Managing Director of Administration and Project Construction stated that the data recording cycle in the @Cow system would be set to once a week for operational agility). Additionally, the operational manual does not clearly define the steps for recording disbursements in the @Con system. Note: The company uses two warehouse management systems: the D-Stre system and the @Con system (for accounting cost recording). Data recording in the D-Stoce system is done immediately or within the day of goods issuance. However, the @Con system does not specify a timeframe for recording.
Incident no longer subject to action

The warehouse management manual should be reviewed to ensure comprehensiveness and alignment with current operations. It should clearly identify the approving authority and specify the timeframe for recording inventory in the @Con system, as per the administration's suggestion. The manual should be disseminated to all warehouse staff to ensure their understanding and strict adherence to the procedures.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Goods Transfer Approval During the project's random document inspection of goods transfer forms, it was found that: - The goods transfer forms from the D-Store system were not approved in accordance with the authorized signatory manual. The signees were the Purchasing Department Head (for transfers from the central warehouse to the project) and the Project Engineer (for transfers between project warehouses). Currently, there is no Director position in the chain of command, and there is no clear objective stated for the transfers. - The goods transfer forms from the @Con system do not have a designated section for authorized signatory approval. In practice, the D-Store goods transfer forms are used as the primary reference.
Incident no longer subject to action

The delegation of authority manual should be reviewed, including the approval activities and authorized personnel, to ensure alignment with actual operations and current job positions. If the proposed approval authority revisions are implemented, the document format for goods transfer forms issued by the D-Store system should also be reviewed. The revised format should clearly specify the purpose of the goods transfer.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Inventory Management and Control A random inventory count conducted on March 13, 2023, revealed discrepancies between the physical inventory and the inventory records in the @Com system. In the Central Warehouse, 15 items showed discrepancies, and the warehouse staff could not explain the reasons. This could be due to outdated recording of receipts and issuances in the system. In the AP Warehouse, there were 2 items with discrepancies due to relocation of storage without updating the location in the system. Observations made on the environmental conditions of the warehouses are as follows: - Central Warehouse: The arrangement of goods is disorganized, scattered, and makes it difficult to locate items. The area surrounding the warehouse, where items such as asbestos pipes and barbed wire fence posts are stored, is overgrown with weeds, obstructing visibility of the stored items. - AP Warehouse: There is a lack of access control or security measures to prevent theft of goods stored outside the warehouse, making it accessible to unauthorized individuals. A significant number of steel bars are placed beside the warehouse, which the warehouse staff explained were items withdrawn by technicians since 2022 but have not yet been utilized.
Implemented

• Operators should be instructed to fully record material receipts and withdrawals in the system. The person responsible for verifying the accuracy and completeness of the recorded transactions should be clearly designated. If any discrepancies or problems are found, the cause should be investigated and corrected immediately without waiting for the accounting department's periodic inventory count.

• The storage area should always be kept organized. If there are any changes to the storage location, the Location in the system should be updated accordingly. In the case of goods stored outside the warehouse, the area should be cleared and the grass trimmed regularly for easy access and control. It should not be placed in an open area; a short fence or lock should be used to prevent loss or theft.

• In the case of goods that have been withdrawn but the contractor has not used them for a long time, the contractor should be contacted to determine when they will be used or if they are no longer needed. The goods should then be managed by either returning them to the warehouse system or ensuring they are stored securely. Goods should only be withdrawn according to the BOQ that will be used for actual construction at that time. Over-withdrawal or withdrawal in excess should be avoided.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Monthly Stocktaking, Summarization, and Approval Process - The documentary evidence summarizing the monthly stocktaking from December 2023 to February 2024 (from the @Con system) lacks credibility. It states that the system quantities, values, and actual counted quantities match for every item in all warehouses, with no discrepancies. This contradicts the cost department's delayed monthly reports and the internal auditor's stocktaking findings. - Only the central warehouse undergoes monthly stocktaking with accounting department participation due to its proximity. Other warehouses, such as the AP and UR warehouses, do not involve accounting in the process. Additionally, the Warehouse Management Manual (DHP-WM-10) lacks clear guidelines on accounting's participation in stocktaking. - Monthly stocktaking summaries lack signatures for acknowledgment and approval, as required by the company's authorization manual (DHP-ICL-06).
Implemented

• A monthly inventory count summary document should be prepared to show the quantity of goods in the system and the quantity of goods actually counted, including the differences from the count. It should also include the causes, supporting evidence, and defined corrective actions or preventive measures, along with designated responsibilities, to prevent discrepancies in inventory quantities, ensure that the balance matches the actual items on hand, and formally report to management.

• The operational manual should specify that accounting personnel participate in the monthly inventory count in all warehouses to ensure verification by unrelated parties and to ensure the reliability of the count results.

• The company should present a monthly inventory count summary document to authorized personnel for acknowledgment and approval in accordance with the designated authorization manual.

Within (month/year)2024-032024-03
Defining Access Rights for Inventory System Users The company's configuration of access rights for the @Con stock system is inappropriate. Issues include: - **Inappropriate access rights for warehouse staff:** Staff members have been granted permissions to modify, delete, and cancel transactions in menus that should be restricted to supervisors. These include adjustments to inventory levels, database modifications, and changes to the monthly values of variables such as SSTOCK, SMATERIAL, and SWIP. - **Unauthorized access for warehouse supervisors and staff:** Both supervisors and staff have been granted access to modes within the system that are not relevant to their roles. This access allows them to add, modify, delete, and cancel data in other modules, such as accounting, BOQ, sales, and accounts receivable.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should review user access and usage rights for the @Con system appropriately. Access should be granted based on job levels and responsibilities as outlined in the Job Description document. Unauthorized individuals should not be granted access to perform any actions within the system.

Within (month/year)2024-062024-06
The policy and work instruction manual review revealed that the current sales and after-sales service policy and work instruction manual do not cover the following actual operations: - The Sales Department's Policy and Criteria for Refund of Contract Deposits and Down Payments (DHIP-SES-01) do not specify the criteria for considering refunds to customers in cases where the customer overpays and in cases where the customer cancels due to personal reasons. - The Sales Department Work Instruction Manual (DHP-WM4-11) does not specify in the process flow and contract process whether a document is issued from the D-Store system, and the receipt issuance process does not specify whether a document is issued from the @Con system.
Incident no longer subject to action

The company should review its policies and manuals/working procedures. It should ensure they cover all important activities and are consistent with current operations, along with clearly proposing them to authorized persons for approval.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Non-compliance with the established manual: There are instances of non-compliance with the Procurement Manual (DHP-WM-04) as follows: - Absence of preparation and storage of the following documents: Price Request Form P/O 01 (replaced by communication via Email and Line), Quotation Form P/O02 (using vendor's quotation document as a substitute), Purchase Order Summary (using details specified in the quotation comparison table instead). - Authorizing signatory cancels purchase orders using the "Purchase Requisition Form P/R03" instead of the designated "Purchase Order Form P/R 03". - In cases of procurement conducted by other departments (excluding construction, such as security personnel, lawyers), there is no documented price comparison process as per the established procedure.
Implemented

The company should review the operating procedures to be appropriate for current operations and submit them to the authorized person for approval and promulgation. In addition, the company should urge employees to proceed and prepare documents according to the specified procedures.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Contract Signing The contract agreement (EM103_1) was signed in the "Employer" section by the Head of Procurement and Cost Control, which is not in accordance with the Authorization Manual (DHP-ICL-05). The approval of the contract agreement (EM103_1) specifies that the authorized person is the Line Director (Acting position held by the Chief Executive Officer).
Incident no longer subject to action

The Employment Agreement (EM103_1) should be signed by an authorized person as specified in the Delegation of Authority Manual. In cases where there are limitations on the availability of the authorized person, delegation of authority should be considered by preparing a Power of Attorney document for a designated representative or a representative of the employer, with the Chief Executive Officer's signature clearly affixed. The delegation of authority should be considered based on the suitability of the duties and job positions.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Use of Petty Cash and Credit Cards for Purchases of Goods and Services - The company has a petty cash policy that does not cover certain important matters. The audit found that petty cash was used to purchase major goods and assets such as fixed assets, office equipment, IT equipment, entertainment expenses, fuel expenses, prepayments for goods, and construction materials. These expenses were incurred by both management and employees. However, there are no defined categories of expenses or appropriate consideration for transactions that should be made through petty cash. Additionally, there is a practice of clearing outstanding petty cash balances into the petty cash fund. - The company has not yet established procedures for using credit cards for purchases. In practice, there are key control measures in place for credit card usage. The credit card used is a TTB Global House credit card, which is only opened and held by authorized personnel. The purpose of this card is specifically for benefits and discounts when purchasing goods from Global House. There are controls in place for the storage and use of the credit card, ensuring that it is only used for purchases that have gone through the procurement process. Additionally, there are control measures for disbursements from the company to settle credit card payments based on actual usage. - Purchases made through petty cash, such as an iPhone 15 Pro and an inkjet printer, have purchase orders (POs) issued. However, there is no evidence of price comparisons being conducted in accordance with appropriate procurement procedures.
Implemented

- The company should review the types of expenses that can be paid from petty cash. The defined expenses should be appropriate, necessary for official business operations, and related solely to the company's operations. Additionally, establish clear guidelines

- For using the ttb Global House credit card to pay for goods, the company should establish clear written procedures, operational steps, and control measures. This includes clear guidelines for handling benefits received from spending through the credit card to prevent related parties from potentially gaining personal benefits from the company's business operations.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Annual Asset Inventory The practice does not comply with the established policy, and the following important information is not prepared: - There is no annual joint asset inventory between the asset maintenance staff and the accounting staff as specified in the policy. - There is no detailed asset inventory plan prepared, specifying which department's assets will be inventoried and when. - Upon completion of the annual inventory, there is no documentation of the inventory, and no inventory report is submitted to authorized personnel.
Implemented

• It should be emphasized that the counting must be carried out in accordance with the established policy. An asset counting plan should be prepared, specifying the types of assets, the time frame for counting, and the person responsible for counting.

• A detailed asset count report should be prepared, clearly stating the details from the count. It should be emphasized that the counter must sign the report for documentation purposes.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Asset Tagging: From the asset inventory sampling, it was found that not all assets have been permanently tagged (1 item found: ARNOLD PAS300 7.5 Sludge Pump due to a missing tag that has not been replaced) and the location of the asset does not match the asset register (1 item found: 51" PLASMA TV, the registered location is Head Office, but the actual item is located at the PS Project showhouse).
Incident no longer subject to action

• For old asset items, the department in control should conduct an inventory and verify against the register. If any discrepancies are found, notify the general property and maintenance officer to take corrective actions according to the established procedures.

• All departments should be informed that

- When a user loses an asset tag or finds a damaged asset tag, immediately notify the relevant department to replace it with a new one.

- When transferring assets, the custodian shall immediately notify the general property and maintenance department to acknowledge and update the inventory or storage location in the system accordingly.

Within (month/year)2024-092024-09
Transfer/Relocation of Fixed Assets: The transfer of fixed assets is not in compliance with established policies, operating manuals, and authorization guidelines. Issues include the lack of clarity regarding responsibility for preparing asset transfer forms, obtaining approval for asset transfers, and the absence of a process for reviewing and updating policies and operating manuals to reflect changes in operations. Additionally, there is no established process for promptly notifying the accounting department of fixed asset transfers or changes in location. This is because the @Con system is primarily used for depreciation calculation and financial reporting purposes by the accounting department, and it does not record asset locations. Consequently, the accounting department is not involved in overseeing or kept informed about these transactions.
Implemented

• Policies, operational manuals, and authorization manuals should be reviewed. These documents should encompass all critical activities and be aligned with current operations.

• Appropriate authorizing personnel for transfers should be considered, such as department head level and above. The general asset and maintenance staff should be informed or clearly designated as an inspector for asset transfers.

• A process for transferring/relocating company assets should be established, requiring notification to the accounting department for every instance. Alternatively, a summary report of asset movement status should be submitted to the accounting department at least once a month.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
Job Description Discrepancies The department and job title information of employees listed in the current employee list does not match the job descriptions and organization chart. DHOUSE: Found 2 employees with discrepancies between their registered job titles, job descriptions, and actual duties. For example: - Accounts Payable Officer - Human Resources and General Administration Officer AGKK: Found 1 employee with a discrepancy between their registered job title, job description, and organization chart. For example: - Internal Secretary - Business Development and Marketing Officer
Incident no longer subject to action

• Job titles in the employee register, job descriptions, job description register, and organizational chart should be reviewed for consistency and updated to reflect the actual positions of employees. The scope, duties, and responsibilities should also be reviewed and aligned with the positions held.

• If there are any changes to the job title in the job description, the employee holding the position should sign an acknowledgment of the updated job description. This serves as evidence of communication regarding the job title, job details, and helps prevent disputes in case of any disagreements regarding responsibilities.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
Employee Transfers within the Group During 2024, there were employee transfers from DHOUSE to AGKK. In practice, the company classifies transfers into two types: temporary transfers/loans (without a new contract) and permanent transfers (with a new contract recognizing prior service). Currently, there are no established procedures or criteria for either type of employee transfer. Additionally, in 2024, the impact of these transfers on employee benefit obligations was not considered, and no adjustments were made to the estimated liabilities in the financial statements of DHOUSE and AGKK.
Implemented

The company should establish clear operational procedures or guidelines for each employee transfer case, such as:

• Document/information preparation, transfer, and approval.

• Whether to prepare a new employment contract/transfer agreement, and the terms of service recognition, between the three parties: the transferring company, the receiving company, and the employee.

• Establishing an agreement outlining the responsibilities for employee benefits and obligations during the transfer between the transferring company and the receiving company, including terms of payment for related expenses incurred. This agreement should encompass employees transferred with continuous service.

• Recording the impact of employee transfers on the estimation of employee benefit liabilities in the financial statements of each company.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
Establishment of a Database for System Access Rights of the Company and Subsidiaries There is no clearly defined database for access rights to the @con, Dtime, Dstore, and Fixed Asset Control systems for each company within the group. Each user's access is granted with varying rights to access each company's data. For example, some users can log in and access both companies' systems, while others can only access one company's system upon login.
Incident no longer subject to action

• A user registry should be established, specifying the access rights of each user for each application of each company, and clearly stating the access rights for each function. The users should correspond to the employee list of each company, and access rights should be granted in accordance with the defined authorization table.

• For the @con system and Fixed Asset control, a list of information system users within the company has already been compiled. The company can add to this information by specifying which company and functions each user can access/use.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
Password Management • The password policy defined in the policy does not match the password policy set in the system. - The specified password length is 6 characters, but the policy specifies 8 characters. - The password expiration is set to 45 days, but the policy specifies 60 days. - There is no limit on the number of incorrect password attempts allowed. • There is no password policy set in the system because the system developer did not define a password policy in the system from the beginning.
Incident no longer subject to action

• Access control and password configurations should be secure, appropriate, and regularly reviewed.

Change passwords regularly.

• Companies should review their password policies to ensure they are appropriate, secure, sufficient, and practical for employees to follow. This helps prevent forgotten passwords and work disruptions.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
The Company's policies, manuals, and working procedures do not cover certain important matters, such as the policy and manual for salary structure determination and the procedures for education/employment history verification. These are currently under review to ensure they are appropriate and aligned with current operations, such as the Human Resources Management Manual (DHP-WM-03).
Implemented

• Operational manuals and relevant policies have been prepared, reviewed, and approved by authorized personnel, except for the policy and regulations regarding salary structure.

• Reviewing all policies and manuals to ensure their scope covers Asset Group Khon Kaen Company Limited.

Within (month/year)2024-122024-12
Employee Onboarding Documentation The preparation, detailing, signing, and filing of employee onboarding documents are incomplete and do not comply with the Human Resource Management Manual (DHP-WM-03). Issues include: - Missing Manpower Request Forms. - Missing Employee Handbook Summary documents in employee files. - Interview Evaluation Forms are missing scores for some criteria. - Incomplete signatures on employment contracts, including missing signatures from the "Employer," "Witness," and "HR representative."
Implemented

• DHOUSE: There were no new employee samples during the inspection.

• AGKK: Human error in document preparation, such as incomplete signatures on probationary employment contracts, incomplete details in documents, and incomplete document preparation.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Company uses the services of an external agency (Outsource) from Owner Audit and Advisory Co., Ltd. to act as the head of internal audit, which has assigned Ms. Piyamart Rueangsangrob to be primarily responsible for performing the duties of the Company's internal auditor to inspect and assess the adequacy of the internal control system and report the audit results to the Audit Committee on a regular basis every quarter. The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of Ms. Piyamart Rueangsangrob and deems her qualified for such duties due to her independence and experience in internal audit work.




Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Related Party Transactions

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
SARAKHAM PETROLEUM COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonRetail Business Office (Gas Station)

- Mr. Chanwit Kaewwisit, Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit, Mrs. Rapiphan Kaewwisit (the mother of Mr. Chanwit and Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit), and Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn collectively hold 100.00% of the shares.

- Mr. Chanwit Kaewwisit, Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit, Mrs. Rapiphan Kaewwisit (the mother of Mr. Chanwit and Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit), and Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn are the authorized directors with signing authority.

2024-12-31T00:00
D ENERGY & RETAIL CO., LTDJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of retailing fuel (gas stations)

DGroup Holdings Co., Ltd. (Subsidiary)

Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn collectively hold 100.00% of the shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
DGROUP HOLDINGS CO., LTD.Juristic PersonEngaged in general wholesale business

DHouse Pattana Public Company Limited

Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn collectively hold 100.00% of the shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
ASSET GROUP KHON KAEN COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in the business of selling non-residential real estate

DHouse Pattana Public Company Limited and Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn collectively hold 100.00% of the shares.

2024-12-31T00:00
FARMMART CORPORATION COMPANY LIMITEDJuristic PersonEngaged in general wholesale business

- Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn collectively hold 100.00% of the shares.

- Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn are the authorized directors with signing authority.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Chaiyut LerdrungpornPerson

- Vice-Chairman of the Company, Director of the Company, Chief Executive Officer (CEO).

- The father of Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, Mr. Att Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, who are the major shareholders of the company and the spouse of Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn.

- Mr. Channarong Kaewwisit and Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mrs. Pranee LerdrungpornPerson

- Director of the Company, Vice-Chairman of the Executive Committee.

- The mother of Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, Mr. Att Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, who are the major shareholders of the company, and the spouse of Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, who is a Director of the Company.

- The aunt of Mr. Channarong Kaewwisit and Mr. Chaichan Kaewwisit.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Pongpot LerdrungpornPerson

- Director of the Company, Authorized Director, Executive Director, Chief Executive Officer (CEO), and holds a 17.74% shareholding.

- The children of Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn and Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Att LerdrungpornPerson

- Director of the Company, Authorized Director, Executive Director, Managing Director of Business Development, Sales, and Marketing, and holds a 17.51% shareholding.

- The children of Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn and Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn.

2024-12-31T00:00
Ms. Nawaporn SanguantrakulPerson

The wife of Mr. Att Lerdrungporn, who is a major shareholder, authorized director, executive director, and managing director of business development, sales, and marketing of the company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Ms. Kritipa KiatsuranonPerson

The wife of Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, who is a major shareholder, director of the company, authorized director, executive director, and chief executive officer (CEO) of the company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr. Krit KiatsuranonPerson

- Shareholder with a 2.77% stake.

- The father of Ms. Krittipa Kiattisuranon, who is the wife of Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, a major shareholder of the company.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
0.19 · Necessity: For use as the company's office location to facilitate the operation of its business. · Description: The company has leased land with the property number 24204, measuring 7 rai, 3 ngan, 63 square wah from Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn, Dr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn, located in Tambon Talat, Muang Maha Sarakham District, Maha Sarakham Province, to be used as the company’s office location for a period of 3 years, starting from June 1, 2019, at a rental rate of 10,000 Baht per month. Later, the company entered into a new lease agreement for a period of 10 years, effective from November 30, 2019, with the option to renew the lease for up to 4 times, each for a period of 10 years. The rental rate was set at 230,000 Baht per year, with a 10% increase in rent every 3 years. On August 13, 2020, the company entered into a new lease agreement to replace the original lease, dividing it based on usage as follows: 1) A lease of land area of 5 rai, 0 ngan, 53 square wah to be used as the company’s office location, with a lease term of 10 years and the option to renew for up to 4 times. The right of use is recorded for a period of 20 years, with an annual rental rate of 149,000 Baht, and rent will be increased by 10% every 3 years. 2) A lease of land area of 2 rai, 3 ngan, 10 square wah to be used as a warehouse, with a lease term of 3 years and the option to renew for up to 10 times. The right of use is recorded for a period of 3 years, with an annual rental rate of 81,000 Baht, and rent will be increased by 10% every 3 years. The rental value was assessed by an approved appraiser from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (Details as per section 2.2.5 - Business assets). As of November 30, 2022, the company extended the lease agreement for the land used for the warehouse for the second time, starting from December 1, 2022, to November 30, 2025, and recorded the right of use for a period of 3 years, with an annual rental rate of 89,100 Baht, which is a 10% increase over the previous rental rate. (Note: 1/ The valuation was done by Sims Property Consultant Co., Ltd., by Mr. Somrak Bongkotprapha, an accredited appraiser under qualification WTH.036, who is a property valuation company approved by the SEC. The land lease including the warehouse (1,840 square meters) was assessed using a market comparison method to determine the asset value under full ownership and rental rate proportions under full ownership for public purposes. The market rental value was assessed as 435,000 Baht per year, with a 10% rental increase every 3 years. This rental value is the combined rent for the land and the warehouse, for which the company has signed lease agreements, divided based on usage and asset ownership. The details are as follows: 1) Land lease contract for 5 rai, 0 ngan, 53 square wah for office use, with a lease term of 10 years and an annual rental rate of 149,000 Baht. 2) Land lease contract for 2 rai, 3 ngan, 10 square wah for warehouse use, with a lease term of 3 years and an annual rental rate of 81,000 Baht. 3) Warehouse lease contract for 3 years, with an annual rental rate of 200,000 Baht.) · As of yesteryear: 0.19 · Nature of transaction: Land rent · Audit committee opinion: The above transaction is related to the lease of assets from related parties. The company has entered into this transaction due to the necessity of conducting its business operations. The rental rate is appropriate and reasonable, based on the appraised value, which is referenced from an independent appraiser approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (Details of the valuation are provided in Attachment 4). · As of year before yesteryear: 0.23 · 0.01 · Necessity: As referred to in item 1 · Description: As referred to in item 1 · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Accrued rent · Audit committee opinion: As referred to in item 1 · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02 · 30.5 · Necessity: The company has borrowed money from Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn to be used as working capital for its business. · Description: The company has borrowed money from Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn to be used as working capital for its business. The company has submitted an application to offer debt securities in the form of a private placement (PP), issuing no more than 10 promissory notes, which are promissory notes with a maturity date to be determined upon demand or upon receipt of payment (at call). The purpose of the loan is to use the funds as working capital for the business, with an interest rate of 1-6% per annum and no collateral. The interest rate is based on the current promissory note loan rate from a commercial bank from which the company has borrowed. · As of yesteryear: 19.0 · Nature of transaction: Loan from related parties · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, with terms and interest rates that are reasonable and intended for the benefit of the company’s business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 42.0 · 0.57 · Necessity: The company has paid interest expense on the loan (as referred to in item 3). · Description: as referred to in item 3 · As of yesteryear: 0.61 · Nature of transaction: Interest expense · Audit committee opinion: as referred to in item 3 · As of year before yesteryear: 0.89 · 0.01 · Necessity: The company has accrued interest on the loan (as referred to in item 3). · Description: as referred to in item 3 · As of yesteryear: 0.05 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest · Audit committee opinion: as referred to in item 3 · As of year before yesteryear: 0.04 · 5.7 · Necessity: The price of the three-story commercial building in the Grand Biz project is the regular price at which the company sells to external parties. · Description: The company has entered into a land and building sales agreement on March 29, 2024, for the Grand Biz project with Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, for Unit 51 (corner unit), with an area of 32 square wah, priced at 4.57 million baht. Additionally, there is an amendment agreement for the demolition of the partition wall between rooms, valued at 0.63 million baht, totaling 5.20 million baht. The price of the three-story commercial building in the Grand Biz project is the regular price set in the company’s Price List, which is sold to external parties. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales · Audit committee opinion: The mentioned transaction is part of the company’s regular business operations, with pricing and terms consistent with those applied to sales to general customers. The company has not provided any special benefit to related parties. Therefore, it is considered that the transaction is appropriate and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
41.5 · Necessity: The company has borrowed money from Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn by entering into a promissory note agreement to be used as working capital for the business. · Description: The company has borrowed money from Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn by entering into a promissory note agreement to be used as working capital for the business. A request has been made for approval to offer debt securities in the form of a private placement (PP) to issue up to 10 promissory notes. The promissory notes are short-term debt securities with a maturity of "at call" (payable upon demand). The purpose is to use the funds as working capital for the business. The interest rate is set at 1% per year, with no collateral required, and the interest rate is referenced from a promissory note loan obtained from a commercial bank. · As of yesteryear: 50.0 · Nature of transaction: Loans from related parties · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended to benefit the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 70.0 · 0.48 · Necessity: The company has paid interest on the loan (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1 · As of yesteryear: 0.67 · Nature of transaction: Interest expenses · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1 · As of year before yesteryear: 0.28 · 0.03 · Necessity: The company has accrued interest on the loan (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 0.04 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.06 · 4.29 · Necessity: The price of the three-story commercial building in the Grand Biz project is the standard price at which the company sells to external parties. · Description: The company entered into a land and building sale agreement on March 29, 2024, for a unit in the Grand Biz project with Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn. The unit, located on Plot 50 with an area of 18 square wah, was sold for 4.29 million baht. The price of the three-story commercial building in the Grand Biz project is the standard price as listed in the company's Price List, which is the same price the company sells to external parties. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from sales · Audit committee opinion: This transaction occurred as part of the company's normal business operations, with pricing and commercial terms that are generally applied, similar to sales to ordinary customers. The company did not provide any special benefits to the related party in this transaction. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
9.0 · Necessity: To be used as working capital in the company's business operations. · Description: The company has borrowed money from Mr. Att Lerdrungporn by entering into a promissory note agreement to be used as working capital for the business. The company has offered to issue up to 10 promissory notes, with the maturity of the debt securities being "at call" (payable upon demand). The purpose is to use the funds as working capital for the business, with an interest rate of 1% per year, referencing the interest rate from a promissory note loan currently obtained from a commercial bank. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Loans from related parties · Audit committee opinion: This transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended to benefit the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.01 · Necessity: The company has paid interest on the loan (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1 · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest expenses · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1 · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.22 · Necessity: The company has rented a multipurpose building to be used for storing materials and equipment for business operations. · Description: The company has leased a building, specifically a multipurpose building, from Mr. Att Lerdrungporn, located on land plot number 24204, Tambon Talat, Mueang Maha Sarakham District, Maha Sarakham Province. The building has a usable area of 1,840 square meters and is intended for storing materials and equipment for business operations. The lease agreement is for a period of 3 years, starting from November 30, 2019, and may be renewed for additional 3-year terms, up to a maximum of 10 times. The company has recorded the asset under the right-of-use category for 3 years, with an annual rent of 200,000 baht. The rental fee is subject to an increase of 10% every 3 years based on the previous rental amount, according to the appraised value, which was assessed by an approved appraiser from the SEC. (Details can be found in section 2.2.5, assets used in business operations). On November 30, 2022, the company renewed the lease for a second term, effective from December 1, 2022, to November 30, 2025, and has recorded the right-of-use asset for the next 3 years, with the rental fee set at 220,000 baht per year, reflecting a 10% increase from the previous rental rate. · As of yesteryear: 0.22 · Nature of transaction: Rental expenses for buildings · Audit committee opinion: This transaction involves leasing an asset from a related party, which the company deemed necessary for its business operations, considering the current circumstances. The rental rate is appropriate and reasonable, in line with the appraised value, which was determined by an independent appraiser approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). (The details of the appraisal can be found in the attached document 4). · As of year before yesteryear: 0.2 · 0.02 · Necessity: The company has accrued rental expenses for the building (as referenced in item 3). · Description: As referenced in item 3. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Accrued rent · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 3. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02
25.0 · Necessity: The company has borrowed money from Mr. Krit Kiatsuranon to be used for the development of real estate projects and as working capital for the company. · Description: The company has borrowed money from Mr. Krit Kiatsuranon for the development of real estate projects and as working capital for the company. The company has submitted an application for approval to issue debt securities in the form of a private placement (PP), offering up to 10 promissory notes. The promissory notes are promissory bills with a maturity date when called or upon receipt of payment (at call), intended to be used as working capital for the business. One note, worth 25 million baht, was offered to Mr. Krit Kiatsuranon. The note was issued on September 16, 2022, with an interest rate of 1% per annum and no collateral, referencing the interest rate of a promissory note loan from a commercial bank that the company currently has. · As of yesteryear: 25.0 · Nature of transaction: Loan from related parties. · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended to benefit the company’s business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 25.0 · 0.25 · Necessity: The company has paid interest on the loan mentioned above (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 0.25 · Nature of transaction: Interest expense · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.56 · 0.02 · Necessity: The company has accrued interest payable on the loan mentioned above (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest payable - related parties · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.02
0.06 · Necessity: The company has purchased fuel for its operations. · Description: The company has purchased fuel for its operations from a service station owned by a related entity, as it is located near the company’s office. The company chose to use this service station for convenience. This transaction is a routine business transaction. · As of yesteryear: 0.12 · Nature of transaction: Real estate development cost · Audit committee opinion: The transaction mentioned above is a normal business transaction, with pricing and terms comparable to those of transactions with external parties. It is reasonable, appropriate, and serves the best interests of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.2
2.4 · Necessity: The company has entered into a lease agreement for the land and buildings of the PTT Gas Station in KhamRiang with D Energy and Retail Co., Ltd. for the purpose of conducting business operations. · Description: The company has entered into a lease agreement for the land and buildings with D Energy and Retail Co., Ltd. for a period of 3 years, from January 1, 2023, to December 31, 2025, with an option to renew the lease for successive periods of 3 years, not exceeding 7 times in total. A security deposit of 5,000,000 baht has been set, and the rent is payable monthly at a rate of 200,000 baht, with an increase of 10% every 3 years based on the previous rental rate. Since there are no comparable rental rates in the nearby area, the company has determined the rental rate based on the estimated depreciation of the leased asset's value, calculating the depreciation rate at 20 years or 5% per year. The rental rate is based on the following data: Leased asset value = 37,222,500 baht Depreciation at 5% per year = 1,861,125 baht Depreciation per month = 155,093.75 baht Therefore, the company has agreed to set the rental rate at 200,000 baht per month to cover the depreciation value of the leased asset. · As of yesteryear: 2.4 · Nature of transaction: Rental income - service station · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is related to the leasing of assets with a related company, which the company deems necessary to enter into for the benefit of its business operations. The rental rate is reasonable and appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 5.0 · Necessity: As referenced in item 1. · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 5.0 · Nature of transaction: Rental security deposit - service station · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.2 · Necessity: As referenced in item 1. · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 0.2 · Nature of transaction: Accrued rental income · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.02 · Necessity: Since D Energy and Retail Co., Ltd. requires office space for document storage and to carry out administrative operations. · Description: The company has agreed to renew the lease for the second year for one office room with a usable area of 16.05 square meters, starting from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2024. The monthly rental rate is 2,000 baht, and a security deposit of 6,000 baht has been set, which is calculated based on 3 months' rent paid in advance. The tenant has the option to renew the lease every year, with a rental increase of 10% every 3 years based on the previous rental rate. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Rental income - office space · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is related to the leasing of assets with a related company, which the company deems necessary to enter into for the benefit of its business operations. The rental rate is reasonable and appropriate. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.01 · Necessity: As referenced in item 4. · Description: As referenced in item 4. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Lease security deposit - office space · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 4. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.18 · Necessity: To align with the operations, practices, and oversight of all aspects of the subsidiary's activities. · Description: To ensure continuity in operations, practices, and oversight of all aspects of the subsidiary's activities, the company has agreed to renew the management services agreement with D Energy and Retail Co., Ltd. for the 2024 fiscal year, from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2024. This agreement is for overseeing accounting tasks in accordance with the law and accounting standards, with a service fee of 15,000 baht per month, for a total contract value of 180,000 baht. The company has determined the service fee based on an estimate of the working hours of the employees managing each department, referencing the salary scale for each year. · As of yesteryear: 0.18 · Nature of transaction: Management fee income · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, reasonable, and serves the purpose of overseeing the accounting tasks to ensure compliance with the law and accounting standards for the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 30.6 · Necessity: To be used as working capital for the business and for the benefit of the company's operations. · Description: The company has borrowed money from D Energy and Retail Co., Ltd. by entering into a promissory note agreement to be used as working capital for the business. The company has submitted an application to offer debt securities in the form of a private placement (PP), offering up to 10 promissory notes. The maturity of the debt securities is structured as a promissory note that is payable on demand or upon receipt of payment (at call), with the purpose of being used as working capital for the business. The interest rate is set at 1-6% per annum, with no collateral, referencing the interest rate of a promissory note loan from a commercial bank that the company currently has. · As of yesteryear: 53.0 · Nature of transaction: Loan from related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended to benefit the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 7.0 · 2.03 · Necessity: The company has paid interest on the loan mentioned above (as referenced in item 7). · Description: As referenced in item 7. · As of yesteryear: 0.82 · Nature of transaction: Interest expense · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 7. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01 · 0.03 · Necessity: The company has accrued interest payable on the loan mentioned above (as referenced in item 7). · Description: As referenced in item 7. · As of yesteryear: 0.14 · Nature of transaction: Accrued interest payable · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 7. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.01
0.01 · Necessity: Since DGroup Holdings Co., Ltd. requires office space for document storage and to carry out administrative operations, · Description: The company has agreed to renew the lease for the second year for one office room with a usable area of 7.74 square meters, from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2024. The monthly rental rate is 1,000 baht, and a security deposit of 3,000 baht has been set, calculated based on 3 months' rent paid in advance. The tenant has the option to renew the lease every year, with a rental increase of 10% every 3 years based on the previous rental rate. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: Rental income - office space · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is reasonable and serves the purpose of benefiting the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
28.5 · Necessity: The company has provided financial assistance to Asset Group Khon Kaen Co., Ltd. for the purpose of obtaining financial support to be used as working capital. · Description: The company has provided financial assistance to Asset Group Khon Kaen Co., Ltd. for the purpose of obtaining financial support to be used as working capital for Asset Group Khon Kaen Co., Ltd. The loan is payable on demand or upon receipt of payment (at call), with the promissory note issued on December 26, 2024, for a total amount of 28.5 million baht, with an interest rate of 6% per annum and no collateral. The interest rate is referenced from a loan obtained by the company from a commercial bank as of November 30, 2024. This loan is intended to support the ongoing business operations of the related company and will not affect the company’s operational results or financial position. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Loan to a related company · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, with reasonable terms and interest rates, and is intended to benefit the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.03 · Necessity: The company has received interest income from the loan mentioned above (as referenced in item 1). · Description: As referenced in item 1. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Interest income · Audit committee opinion: As referenced in item 1. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 0.03 · Necessity: To ensure continuity in operations and the oversight of accounting tasks of the subsidiary, in compliance with legal requirements and accounting standards. · Description: To ensure continuity in operations and the oversight of accounting tasks of the subsidiary, the company has agreed to enter into a management services agreement with Asset Group Khon Kaen Co., Ltd. for the fiscal year 2024, from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2024, to manage the accounting tasks in compliance with legal requirements and accounting standards. The service fee is set at 2,500 baht per month, with a total contract value of 30,000 baht. The service fee rate was determined based on the estimated working hours of the employees handling tasks in each department, referencing the salary scale. · As of yesteryear: 0.02 · Nature of transaction: Management fee income · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is necessary, reasonable, and serves the purpose of benefiting the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 54.0 · Necessity: To expand the real estate development business into Khon Kaen province, which has high potential in terms of purchasing power. Khon Kaen is adjacent to Maha Sarakham province, allowing the company to control costs in managing and developing projects, as well as helping the company expand its customer base. · Description: At the board of directors meeting on October 17, 2023, the meeting considered and approved the acquisition of assets through the purchase of common shares in Asset Group Khon Kaen Co., Ltd. ("AGKK") in the amount of 54,000 shares, with a par value of 1,000 baht per share, representing 100% of the total shares. The purchase price was 1,000 baht per share (equal to the par value), resulting in a total transaction value of 54,000,000 baht. Following the transaction, the company holds a 100% stake in AGKK, making AGKK a subsidiary of the company. This transaction enables the company to acquire land with high potential in Khon Kaen province, consisting of 61 plots totaling 299 rai, 1 ngan, and 24.8 square wah, with a total appraised value of 85,250,618 baht, as appraised by Real Estate Appraisal Co., Ltd. on August 15, 2023. The appraisal was conducted for public purposes. The company plans to expand its real estate development business into Khon Kaen, which has high purchasing power. Khon Kaen is adjacent to Maha Sarakham, allowing the company to control costs in managing and developing projects, while also helping to expand the company's customer base. This will likely lead to improved business performance. · As of yesteryear: 54.0 · Nature of transaction: Investment in subsidiary - Asset Group Khon Kaen · Audit committee opinion: The transaction is reasonable and serves the purpose of benefiting the company's business operations. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
5.7 · Necessity: Since the vehicles were not being utilized effectively by the company, they were sold in order to reduce the company’s expenses, such as vehicle tax, insurance, and maintenance costs, and to benefit the company. · Description: On September 26, 2023, the Board of Directors approved the sale of two vehicles from the company to Farm Mart Corporation Limited, a related legal entity. The vehicles were a TOYOTA ALPHARD 2.5 valued at 3.5 million baht and a TOYOTA ALPHARD 2.4 valued at 2.2 million baht. These vehicles were not being utilized effectively by the company. Therefore, to reduce expenses such as vehicle tax, insurance, and maintenance costs, the Board approved the sale of these vehicles. On September 30, 2023, the company entered into two vehicle sales contracts as follows: 1) A sales agreement for a TOYOTA ALPHARD 2.5 Hybrid E-Four Welcab 4WD Van, white color, with a sales price of 3.5 million baht. 2) A sales agreement for a TOYOTA ALPHARD 2.4 HV 4WD Van, white color, with a sales price of 2.2 million baht. The sales prices of these vehicles were based on market prices. These transactions were not part of the company’s normal business operations. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Sale of vehicles · Audit committee opinion: The transactions mentioned above are not part of the company's normal business operations. The prices and terms of the transaction were compared with market prices, which are reasonable, appropriate, and in the best interest of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
24.93 · Necessity: The price of the 3-story home office building at The Grand Canal project is the regular price that the company sells to external parties. · Description: As of September 30, 2024, the company has entered into a sales contract for land and a 3-story home office building at The Grand Canal project with the Lerdrungporn family group and related individuals, including Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, Ms. Kritipa Kiatsuranon, and Ms. Nawaporn Sanguantrakul. A total sales value of 24.93 million baht. · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: Revenue from Sales · Audit committee opinion: This transaction is part of the company’s normal business operations, with pricing and trading terms consistent with those applied to regular customers. The company has not provided any special benefit to the related parties involved. Therefore, it is concluded that this transaction is appropriate and reasonable. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

Approval Process and Procedures for Related Party Transactions

In cases where the company has transactions with related parties or individuals who may have a conflict of interest, a stake in the transaction, or a potential future conflict of interest, such transactions must be conducted under normal business terms, similar to agreements that an informed party would enter into with an external counterpart in the same situation. This should be done with bargaining power free from any influence due to their status as directors, executives, or related individuals, and under conditions that are reasonable, verifiable, and do not result in the transfer of benefits. The company’s management can proceed with such transactions under the principles that have been approved by the Board of Directors. Additionally, a summary report must be provided to the Audit Committee for review on a quarterly basis.

In cases where the transaction is not a regular business transaction, the company will ensure that the Audit Committee provides an opinion on the necessity and appropriateness of such transactions. If the Audit Committee lacks the expertise to evaluate potential related party transactions, the company will consider obtaining opinions from independent appraisers, specialized experts, or auditors regarding the transaction. This opinion will be submitted to the Audit Committee to assist in making decisions and providing recommendations to the Board of Directors or shareholders, as appropriate, to approve the transaction before it is executed. The company will disclose all related party transactions in the notes to the financial statements that have been audited by the company’s auditors. Additionally, such transactions will be disclosed in the annual report (Form 56-1) as required by the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules and regulations set by the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The approval process for related party transactions will comply with the relevant securities laws and regulations, as well as the regulations, announcements, orders, and rules of the Stock Exchange of Thailand. Individuals with conflicts of interest or stakes in the transaction will not have the right to vote on these related party transactions.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

In the future, if the company needs to engage in transactions with parties who may have a conflict of interest with the company, the company will set the terms in accordance with normal business practices and market prices, which can be compared with the terms or prices applicable to similar transactions with external parties. The Audit Committee will provide opinions regarding pricing, compensation rates, as well as the necessity and appropriateness of the related transactions. In cases where the Audit Committee lacks the expertise to evaluate the potential transactions, the company will consider obtaining opinions from independent appraisers, specialized experts, or the company’s auditors to assist the Audit Committee in making informed decisions and providing recommendations to the Board of Directors or shareholders as appropriate.

Any potential related party transactions in the future will comply with the guidelines set by the SEC and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. Directors must not approve any transactions in which they or related parties may have conflicting interests. Such transactions must be disclosed to the Board of Directors for consideration. The company will strictly adhere to the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, announcements, orders, or rules of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including complying with the disclosure requirements for related party transactions and acquisitions or disposals of the company's assets, as well as accounting standards set by the Association of Accountants.

Moreover, the company will not engage in related party transactions that do not involve regular business operations.

For the current ongoing related party transactions, these include:

1) Leasing land from Mr. Chaiyut Lerdrungporn, Mrs. Pranee Lerdrungporn, Dr. Pongnarin Lerdrungporn, Mr. Pongpot Lerdrungporn, and Mr. Att Lerdrungporn for the company’s office location. The rental price is based on an appraisal price using market comparison methods, as assessed by an asset valuation firm approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission.

2) Leasing property from Mr. Att Lerdrungporn for the storage of business materials. The rental price follows an appraisal based on market comparison methods, as assessed by an asset valuation firm approved by the Securities and Exchange Commission.

3) Purchasing fuel from Sarakham Petroleum Co., Ltd. for operational purposes. The company has compared prices and terms with other suppliers, and the terms are not different from those offered to regular business partners, including considerations of the proximity of the supplier to the company’s office.

4) Leasing a fuel station from D Energy & Retail Co., Ltd. for its operations. The rental price is calculated based on the depreciation of the leased asset, using an approximate depreciation rate of 5% per year (20 years). This is because there are no comparable rental prices available in the surrounding area.

Regarding loans from directors and related parties, the company has a policy to reduce reliance on loans from directors and related parties. The company intends to raise funds from its own sources, including by issuing bonds, which provides sufficient working capital for its operations, eliminating the need to depend on loans from directors.

Contents